Arnold A. Arpino & Associates P.C.
Case Result: Wyoming County Traffic Charge Dismissed After the People Concede the Supporting Deposition Did Not Support the Offense Charged
Back to blog
Traffic DefenseDavid Arpino, Esq.

Case Result: Wyoming County Traffic Charge Dismissed After the People Concede the Supporting Deposition Did Not Support the Offense Charged

On November 10, 2026, Warsaw Village Court in Wyoming County dismissed a traffic charge against our client. The People did not oppose the dismissal. In their answering papers, they acknowledged that the officer's supporting deposition did not establish reasonable cause to believe our client committed the offense written on the ticket.

The lesson is simple. Read the ticket, then read the deposition, and make sure they describe the same offense.

The charge

Our client, an out-of-state driver, was stopped in the Village of Warsaw in June 2026 and issued a simplified traffic information charging one violation of Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1110(a), disobeying a traffic control device. The officer provided a supporting deposition along with the ticket.

What the deposition said, and what it left out

VTL § 1110(a) requires every person to "obey the instructions of any official traffic-control device applicable to him." To support that charge, the People need facts showing three things: an official sign, signal, or marking; that it applied to the driver; and that the driver did not do what it instructed.

The deposition in this case contained none of them. Its narrative was about speed from beginning to end: a dispatch report of cars driving fast, the officer's visual estimate of our client's speed, and a statement our client allegedly made at the roadside. No sign, signal, or marking was mentioned anywhere. The only reference to the offense charged was the phrase "disobeyed traffic control device," entered in the field that describes the violation.

Speed is not an element of VTL § 1110(a). A deposition can describe fast driving in detail and still say nothing about whether the driver disobeyed a traffic control device. And a court deciding facial sufficiency cannot fill the gap by assuming there was a posted sign that the officer never mentioned.

The rule

Under CPL 100.25(2), a supporting deposition must contain allegations of fact "providing reasonable cause to believe that the defendant committed the offense or offenses charged." When a deposition is served and falls short of that standard, the simplified traffic information is insufficient on its face (CPL 100.40[2]; People v. Key, 45 NY2d 111 [1978]; People v. Hohmeyer, 70 NY2d 41 [1987]). Repeating the name of the offense is a conclusion, not a fact.

The motion and the result

In August 2026, David Arpino of our firm moved to dismiss the charge as facially insufficient. In the alternative, he moved to suppress the alleged roadside statement or for a Huntley hearing, and asked the court under CPL 340.50(2) to allow our client, who lives out of state, to appear through counsel if the case went to trial.

In November, the People answered. They acknowledged that the deposition did not identify a particular traffic control device, describe the instruction it conveyed, or specify how our client disobeyed it, and they did not oppose dismissal on facial sufficiency grounds. The court dismissed the charge.

What this means if you have a traffic ticket in New York

A ticket is an accusation, and the paperwork behind it has to support the specific charge the officer chose. If you were given a supporting deposition with your ticket, or you requested one, compare it to the charge. Does it state facts for each element of that offense, or does it describe something else? Two cautions. First, these issues should be raised in a written motion before any plea, and the deadlines are short. Second, a dismissal for facial insufficiency is not a ruling on the merits. The People asked here that the dismissal be without prejudice, and the Court of Appeals has held that a dismissal of this kind does not by itself bar a new prosecution on a legally sufficient accusatory instrument (People v. Nuccio, 78 NY2d 102 [1991]). Every case turns on its own paperwork.

If you received a traffic ticket anywhere in New York State, call us at 631-724-5251 or email intake@arpinopc.com for a consultation.

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Client-identifying details have been omitted to protect confidentiality.

Case ResultsWyoming CountyTraffic TicketsCPL 100.25

Facing Criminal Charges on Long Island?

Our former public defenders are ready to fight for you. Free consultation — no obligation.

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.