Arnold A. Arpino & Associates P.C.
Case Result: Suffolk County Harassment Charge Dismissed When the People's Witness Failed to Appear for Trial
Back to blog
Criminal DefenseDavid Arpino, Esq.

Case Result: Suffolk County Harassment Charge Dismissed When the People's Witness Failed to Appear for Trial

A client charged with harassment in the second degree (Penal Law § 240.26) in Suffolk County First District Court recently walked out with a full dismissal. We had pressed the case for months, including a discovery and speedy-trial challenge that the court ultimately denied. When we refused to plead and set the matter down for trial, the prosecution's witness did not show up, and the People had no choice but to dismiss.

This case is a good illustration of something we tell clients often: losing a motion is not losing the case.

The charge

Our client was arrested in early 2026 after an alleged physical altercation, given an appearance ticket, and arraigned in First District Court in Central Islip on a charge of harassment in the second degree, a violation under Penal Law § 240.26. From the first court date, we treated it like a case that would go to trial.

The discovery fight under CPL Article 245

Our client had filed a complaint with the Suffolk County Police Department's Internal Affairs Bureau against the arresting officer and had already been interviewed by IAB. Under CPL 245.20(1), material bearing on the credibility of a testifying officer is discoverable, so on the day of arraignment we put the assigned prosecutor on written notice and demanded the IAB file.

The People filed their Certificate of Compliance and Statement of Readiness on the 30th day after arraignment, the last day of the speedy-trial clock for this charge under CPL 30.30(1)(d). That package did not include the IAB interview recording. The recording arrived eleven days later in a supplemental certificate.

We moved to strike the certificate as illusory and to dismiss under CPL 30.30. Our position was that a certificate filed without the IAB material was not a valid statement of readiness, relying on the Appellate Term's decision in People v. Edwards, 88 Misc 3d 132(A) (App Term, 2d Dept, 9th & 10th Jud Dists 2025), which invalidated a certificate filed before IAB audio was turned over.

The court's ruling, and why we kept going

The court denied the motion. Applying People v. Bay, 41 NY3d 200 (2023), it found that the People had documented enough follow-up with their Special Productions Unit and IAB to show due diligence, and distinguished Edwards on the ground that the prosecution there had admitted making no effort beyond monitoring the IAB log. The court also found no prejudice from the delayed disclosure of our client's own interview.

We disagreed with the result, but the ruling did not change our strategy. The motion had forced the People to put their entire discovery timeline on the record, confirmed that the IAB investigation was open and active, and made clear that we were not going to plead this case out.

Trial day

We answered ready. The People's witness failed to appear. With no witness, the People could not go forward, and the case was dismissed.

What this means if you are charged in Suffolk County

Harassment and other low-level charges are often treated as cases to plead out quickly. They should not be. A dismissed case is sealed under CPL 160.50 as though the arrest never happened; a plea, even to a violation, can follow you.

Three things made the difference here:

  1. We demanded discovery in writing on day one and documented every follow-up.
  2. We litigated the certificate of compliance and speedy-trial issues fully, even knowing the law under Bay is unfavorable to the defense.
  3. We were prepared to try the case. Prosecutors and complaining witnesses respond differently when they know the defense will actually try the case.

If you or a family member has been charged with harassment, assault, or any misdemeanor in Suffolk County District Court or a local justice court, call us at 631-724-5251 or email intake@arpinopc.com for a consultation.

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Client-identifying details have been omitted to protect confidentiality.

Case ResultsSuffolk CountyCPL 30.30Discovery

Facing Criminal Charges on Long Island?

Our former public defenders are ready to fight for you. Free consultation — no obligation.

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.