We’re excited to share a significant win from the courtroom today. We successfully obtained a dismissal of all charges for my client in a recent case in Suffolk County District Court in Central Islip, New York. Our client was charged with harassment in the second degree. The motion to dismiss was based on the violation of our client’s right to a speedy trial, and we’re pleased to report that the court granted the motion, with the People consenting to the dismissal without opposition. Not only was the charge dismiss, but a stay away order of protection that was previously issued was vacated too.
A critical factor in this case was the prosecution’s failure to meet their obligations under the law. Specifically, the District Attorney’s office made a significant error by transmitting the statement of trial readiness and related discovery materials to the incorrect attorney. Despite knowing that an attorney from our firm had been appointed to represent the client, the prosecution failed to promptly notify David Arpino, the defense attorney of record, about their readiness for trial. Instead, the District Attorney’s office delivered these materials to the Suffolk County Legal Aid Society. This oversight caused an unnecessary delay, which ultimately exceeded the time allowed under the law for speedy trial.
This outcome reaffirms the importance of holding the prosecution accountable to procedural requirements, such as timely communication of trial readiness and proper service of discovery materials. In this case, the prosecution’s failure to comply with these requirements led directly to the dismissal of charges against our client.
Every case is unique, and this victory underscores the value of a diligent and detailed defense. Ensuring that every procedural safeguard is observed can make all the difference in achieving a just outcome.
If you or someone you know is facing criminal charges, remember that time is of the essence, and a strong defense begins the moment you are charged. Don’t hesitate to reach out for expert legal guidance.